What Indeed’s 2026 Changes Have Done to Hiring Costs

Throughout the year, one of the most regular conversations we’ve had with employers has been that they are seeing less traffic and their budget is bringing in fewer people.

We wanted to know how widespread that was and what we could do to optimize the budget our clients have, so we looked at every Indeed campaign we managed from January through late October 2026 and compared it with the same dates in 2025.

Here is what we found, and how it shapes the way we work with our clients to plan today and into 2027.

1. Free applicants have nearly disappeared

From January through late October 2025, organic applicants made up roughly 10 to 25 percent of everyone who started an application on our clients’ campaigns (depending on the month). Over the same timeframe in 2026, they made up under 10 percent. For most employers, the free share fell from roughly 10 to 20 percent to under 10 percent, and the number of free applicants dropped by roughly 35 to 85 percent.

The slide started in the spring of 2025 and kept going, and as we approach 2027, Indeed has become more open about the direction. Its own guidance says free posts can lose visibility quickly and stop showing after 30 days if they are posted directly on Indeed. Also, as of March 31, 2026, jobs posted onto Indeed, when an employer also has an applicant tracking system connected to Indeed, appear only when they are sponsored.

What we do: Plan every budget as if paid applicants will carry nearly all of the load. Any free applicants that still come in are a bonus, not part of the plan.

2. The same money bought fewer applications

Across all accounts the average cost per application increased from about $5.00 to about $6.50.

Because the mix of employers we support changed between the two years, we also looked only at the employers who advertised steadily in both periods. For most of them, cost per application rose by up to about a third, and the cost of a click ranged from about 5 percent lower to about 35 percent higher. Counting free and paid applicants together, the cost for each person who started an application rose roughly 10 to 60 percent for most of them. That gap is the free traffic that went away.

What we do: We build each plan based on an employer’s own recent cost per application, not last year’s. If a budget was built when free applicants filled part of the gap, it needs a fresh look.

3. Steady costs came from matching budget to need

Not everyone paid more. Over half of our clients have held their cost per application within 10 percent of 2025 or brought it down. And for most within that group, application volume kept pace with spend. For the rest, cost per application rose roughly 25 to 30 percent.

A national pest control client is a good example. Through September, its spend and its applications each grew by about 5 to 10 percent, and its cost per application held near $10 in both years. We built its budget branch by branch from each branch’s own results and pulled paid support back from branches that did not need it. You can read the full pest control case study.

What our clients who held their costs in check had in common:

  • A variable budget for every job and location, built from that location’s own cost per application
  • Paid support pulled back where a location was already staffed
  • Premium used for urgent openings, with a set end date
  • Plain, searchable job titles across every location
  • Success analyzed every week, not once a month


4. Premium placement: the right tool for your hardest openings

Indeed’s Premium Sponsored Jobs go beyond standard sponsorship. A premium job can carry an “Urgently hiring” label and your company’s logo and banner, and it lets you invite matched candidates to apply directly.

In 2026, premium made up 10%+ of our clients’ spend. All that extra reach has a price: in almost every account that used both, each application cost more than standard sponsorship, up to about twice as much. But it often reaches people more ready to apply. In our restaurant hiring data, people who clicked a premium manager ad completed an application about a fifth more often than people who clicked a standard one, and busy premium postings typically reached 20 applications in one to two and a half days, against two to four days on standard.

That fits how Indeed describes Premium Sponsored Jobs: better placement and tools to reach candidates who fit the role. For a role that has to be filled now, that is often a trade worth making.

What we do: We help you choose which openings deserve premium, set an end date, and make full use of what it includes, from the urgent hiring label to inviting candidates to apply. Everything else stays on standard sponsorship so your budget goes further.

5. Keep titles plain, and use a bonus when it helps a job stand out

Job seekers search for plain role names, like “Line Cook,” “Server” or “Pest Control Technician,” and Indeed’s own posting standards ask employers to keep titles simple, short, and accurate.

A bonus is the exception that’s worth using when a job is hard to fill. Our clients saw that adding a sign on bonus to the title drew more clicks in our data when compared to no bonus in similar situations. And while the application rate was slightly lower, by having more eyes and clicks on the ad, cost per application came out about even, sometimes better and sometimes worse. 

What we do: We start every job with the plain role name that’s standardized so when a job seeker searches, it’s matched to them more readily. For hard to fill openings offering a real sign on or stay bonus, we test it in the title and keep it only if applications and cost per application hold up. Pay, schedules and hiring dates go in the posting itself, where candidates read them before they apply and it reduces clutter.

Let’s look at your data! 

If your Indeed budget is buying fewer applicants than it used to, we would be glad to show you where the money is going and how we would plan the year ahead. Book a Consultation or contact our team. You can also read more about how we work with Indeed.

About these numbers: Indeed campaigns we manage, January 1 to October 27, 2025 and 2026. Ranges show the middle half of employers unless noted as month to month.